Best Way to Convey Information? Yup, Still Text.

The laugh of the day is 3D Mailbox, a somewhat bizzarre application which can best be described as a cross between plain old e-mail and Second Life. Suffice to say that it’s not really useful.

I’ve read about 3D mailbox in a great interview with Richard Bartle, one of the creators of MUD (Multi User Dungeon), which is a general name for a variety of text (and sometimes, ASCII graphics) based virtual world that were popular in the nineties, and had me hooked to my computer for a couple of years. Read it up, it’s good stuff.

But, the 3D Mailbox story made me think about 3D interfaces, virtual worlds, and GUIs of the future. And, once again, I came to the exact same conclusion.

The interface of the future is text-based.

Not text-based as in console; the text can be arranged in windows, or bars, or in any other way, and combined with images and videos. But, the main and the important part of future GUIs will still be plain old text.

Bartle says it well: “Would you want to read what I’m saying here if it were in a 3D setting? Would it help or hinder your ability to follow what was going on?” Perhaps my imagination sucks, but save for futurist idea about plugging your brain directly into the computer, I can’t see a better way of exchanging information (with other people or with your computer) than through a text-based keyboard and a text-based GUI.

This is why I don’t really believe in 3D interfaces, 3D-based apps, and virtual worlds in the sense that they’re going to replace our good old 2D way of communicating with a computer. Everything that makes it harder for us to enter text (e.g. iPhone) is not a good idea. 3D Mailbox? Definitely not a good idea - it would have to be insanely cool, fast, and funny to work. Actually, here’s a rule of thumb for developers: if your idea makes it harder for people to do stuff they normally do, it’s going to have to be 10 times as good as anything else out there to be successful.

34 Responses to “Best Way to Convey Information? Yup, Still Text.”

  1. Kristjan in Tallinn™ » Blog Archive » 3D Mailbox - aga milleks? Says:

    […] Sattusin just lugema franticindustries Stani juttu sellest millisele järeldusele on ta jõudnud tuleviku GUI võimalikust lahendusest. Tekstipõhine loomulikult! Põhjuseks lihtsalt, et see on inimesele kõige mõistetavam ja arvatavasti ka tulevikus. […]

  2. Michael Says:

    After reading this I thought I would leave a note about a tool and client of mine that might help people think about their communications and be useful to your readers.

    This might be helpful for you guys. A client of mine has a new free email program with self-destructing email, email you can’t print or forward and free video email. Check out:

    http://www.BigString.com

    It is a new free webmail program. When you send mail from your BigString account, you are protected. BigString is like an automatic shredder for your email. You can self-destruct or change an email that’s already been sent or read.

    Ever send that email to your boss at 2AM ranting, or a picture of your girlfriend to your mom by mistake, just have one of those “DOH” moments you wish you could bring it back, try this tool!

    Have a great day!
    Michael
    michaelf@bigstring.com

  3. Robert Frost Says:

    Gee, *thanks*, SPAMMER!!!!!

  4. Mazariegos Says:

    I’m glad I saw this, kudos!

  5. Lubbs Says:

    Excellent blog, I’ll be coming back to visit more often now. Keep up the great work.

  6. Shuffield Says:

    Hello,

    very nice blog, good work, nice to read.

    regards

    Reifen

  7. Lesesne Says:

    Do you write the articles yourself or do you get somebody to write out your ideas for me? As when i tried blogging I was nowhere near this good!

  8. Nipper Says:

    Ha!

    You would think that they world have OK’d it at the beginning instead of allowing it to go so long without saying a thing and then bringing it back up when it was too late. I don’t understand it at all. Semenax

  9. Spengler Says:

    Hey there, Great Articl! Feel free to submit your site to our Directory Free. http://www.bestlistingz.com

  10. Sak Says:

    Ha!

    You would think that they world have OK’d it at the beginning instead of allowing it to go so long without saying a thing and then bringing it back up when it was too late. I don’t understand it at all. Elk Antler Aphrodisiac

  11. Cerreta Says:

    I really hope this works…

  12. Warburton Says:

    Excellent post, keep it up

  13. Stankovich Says:

    OMG Pam Anderson Is Flabby Now Look At These Bikini Pics That Are Taken Of Her Recently!

  14. Avery Says:

    Excellent post, keep it up

  15. Haga Says:

    Excellent post, keep it up

  16. Mccutchan Says:

    Excellent post, keep it up

  17. Alipio Says:

    Awesome info! I was honestly just thinking about something similar to this the other day so, it was almost “weird” when I ran across this. You would be surprised how many people simply have no idea when it comes to this kind of stuff. Anyway, thanks for getting this info out there and I’m sure I’m not the only one who appreciates you taking the time to post this for the masses.

  18. BuythePill Says:

    What a great article… it’s one of the best ones I’ve read in a while! I’ll definetly be subscribing to this blog. Thanks for a good read

  19. Keehn Says:

    That was a great post…I love this site…Thanks

  20. Pluck Says:

    Free iPhone 3G http://www.yourfree3giphone.info

  21. Gurner Says:

    Love this post! Great blog! I’m doing articles on Super Smash Bros Brawl feel free to write back sometime! http://www.rofasbiweeklies.info

  22. Gigler Says:

    Thanks for the interesting article

    http://goodoletom.com/store

  23. Arvie Says:

    I Love the way you write…thanks for posting

  24. Braatz Says:

    My favorite file hosting service is www.m9dia.com. Unlike other hosting services, m9dia does not have any advertising, waiting times, queues, download limits or whatsoever.

  25. Ravert Says:

    Awesome buddy. Its great and such an amazing thing. I would add this to my rss feed :) http://www.theantoniobanderas.com

  26. Moskowitz Says:

    I Love the way you write…thanks for posting

  27. Minto Says:

    I Love the way you write…thanks for posting

  28. Hopes Says:

    I Love the way you write…thanks for posting

  29. Hohlfeld Says:

    I Love the way you write…thanks for posting

  30. Tooles Says:

    I’m just new to your blogsite and I just read your blog you have a nice post it’s worth to reading it. I’m beginning to start love reading some blogs and hoping some time I can built a blogs this thing’s getting better and better as I learn more about it. Nice work on your blog. Everything was above and beyond what I expected.

  31. Grabe Says:

    thanks! just what I was looking for :)

  32. Desjarlais Says:

    thanks! just what I was looking for :)

  33. Calcano Says:

    thanks! just what I was looking for :)

  34. Gilley Says:

    Hello Friends!!

    Guaranteed Horse Racing Profits Over ?1000 http://thailearne.dutchand.hop.clickbank.net/?tid=horse Please insert a URL or HTML Link

Leave a Reply