Everything counts in large amounts - Technorati gaming
It’s no secret that Technorati’s top lists can be gamed with some relatively simple techniques. Technorati bases its popularity rankings on the number of inbound links, and, like everything else, the number of inbound links can be blown up through artificial means. Same goes for Techorati’s list of top favorited blogs, and the latest way to game this list is the “Technorati favorites exchange meme”. It’s a simple “I rub your shoulder, you rub mine” type of strategy where those who thought of it first fare well while others down the chain get breadcrumbs.
Now, some might say that this is a perfectly legitimate “strategy” of increasing the position of your blog on Technorati, but it’s not, because it has nothing to do with the concept of favorites. The idea behind Google’s PR algorithm and Technorati rankings is to measure natural links and natural favorites. In the following example, a blog that almost entered the top 100 Technorati favorited blogs has a Technorati ranking of 62.417. See a discrepancy here?
Furthermore, this type of mindless favorite reciprocating is creating an inflation of favorite links which will in turn make it impossible for any new site to reach the heights of the top 100 list through any natural means (natural meaning people actually liking the site, and adding it to favorites because they like it).
The same goes for MyBlogLog, whose widget I’ve removed from the site. One reason I did this was it slowing down the site, but another, equally important reason was that the service was getting far from the ideal of being a place to find new interesting sites. It is becoming more of a spamfest, breeding various XXXXk bloggers projects with absolutely no other value or purpose than to get high on MyBlogLog’s top lists.
This is a pattern that emerges in many others (if not all) social media sites. Whenever there’s a benefit from sheer volume of friends, favorites, or any other type of link in a network, people will start abusing it by going for sheer quantity. On Digg, if you want to be a successful submitter, it pays off to have a lot of friends. Where does that lead? Into friend-inflation; users are adding thousands of friends in hope that they’ll reward their “friendship” by voting for their stories. After a while, it gets pointless, because it’s impossible to actually follow what all those friends are doing, but there’s no turning back because your value in this particular social network is largely determined by the number of friends you have.
The solution? Fix the algorithms to put much more emphasis on the quality than the quantity of links. Punish reciprocating patterns by reducing the ranks of sites which indulge in such practices. Right now, everything counts in large amounts - and it’s hurting the user experience on social media sites.
*update: completely by accident, as I’ve finished writing this article, I noticed a hefty increase in the Technorati rank for FranticIndustries, which now sits in the top 2700 sites - an increase of approx. 400 spots. Since there was no huge burst of new links towards the site, I reckon that this might be some kind of severe correction on Technorati’s part, which devalued sites with bogus links and rewarded sites with quality links (this site has a really solid number of links from highest quality sites). If this is the case, good job.
April 30th, 2007 at 4:23 am
Hi Stan,
Actually my site did make it into 100, there is another post on my blog about it. By the way “100 most favorited” and “100 most linked to” are two different lists. 62.417- this number changes as other blogs link to you, jut like you did here in this article. Favorite Exchange has nothing to do with linking therefore a blog can rank at 1,000,000 and still enter the top 100. You should try it maybe.
April 30th, 2007 at 5:43 am
I’ve favorited you Stan, now how’s about returning the favor.
April 30th, 2007 at 6:53 am
@Vlad: I’m aware that “most favorited” and the standard Technorati lists are two different lists. I also know they’re not directly connected. I think it’s visible from the text, if you read it carefully.
There have been more or less successful attempts to somehow game both lists, and in all these cases I think that it’s a sad attempt at getting up the social media ladder. It’s most blatantly visible at MyBlogLog, where sites put dozens of exclamation marks in front of their names to be on top, and spam other users for links. The Technorati favorite is not that bad, but it’s still an unnatural way of increasing your rank at that particular list.
@Ali: I don’t favorite many blogs on Technorati simply because I don’t use the service for reading blogs. You’ve got a direct link from me, though (:
April 30th, 2007 at 11:01 am
[…] Recent news about technorati favorites being gamed has surfaced. This has been happening for quite sometime now and not just with the favorites, but also with their rankings as well. Its quite simple actually, you start a blog post train by adding your friends they then add you back and then whoever takes part has to add all the blogs on the list and it keeps going and going. […]
April 30th, 2007 at 11:19 am
@stan
yeah i know I was just kidding. blog on man!
April 30th, 2007 at 12:57 pm
What Does Your Tag Cloud Say About You?…
It is incredibly important to focus your content to one field, niche, or industry and try to deviate from it as little as possible. The mark of a good blog is how consistently focused its content is, and a quick way to judge blogs in this respect is to…
April 30th, 2007 at 12:57 pm
[…] Other bloggers discussing this topic are: Digital Inspiration O’Flaherty Nick Rugjeff Frantic Industries I mostly disagree with the above blogs but I link to them so you can read the opposing viewpoint if you like. If you do, check out my comment at O’Flaherty (unless he removed it). Hahaha! Hey, he called me a whore first, what’d you expect? […]
April 30th, 2007 at 5:41 pm
Stan,
To be honest I hesitate whether or not to participate. Nevertheless I am pleased with the results. Making 100 is not a big deal, blogs like yours, if they chose to can reclaim their positions within days, after a single post. And those who made the list during the meme will have a hard time catching up.
To me the most beneficial part of the meme was that I have come across many wonderful blogs, just like you have here. So for what is worth, it was not such a bad idea. As a “side effect” I do have rather large OPL file. But with some creativity this file can be put to good use.
By the way, thanks for the link.
May 3rd, 2007 at 7:07 am
@Vlad: no problem (;.
May 4th, 2007 at 5:02 am
Anyone who quotes Depeche Mode is cool by me.
May 30th, 2007 at 10:17 pm
superman gay leather…
superman gay leather …
June 15th, 2007 at 6:46 am
Good that they’ve fixed it!
July 18th, 2007 at 6:51 am
[…] Since I’ve started blogging, a very personal experience, I’ve begun pondering the deep questions of life. How much traffic am I getting, how do I get more traffic, how’s the feeds doing… you know those basic life questions. It turns out that there is a significant part of the blogging world devoted to those very same questions and I’m not sure how I feel about it. Others have noticed this same thing. […]
April 9th, 2009 at 9:51 am
tennessee nursing assi
new jersey nursing homes
April 11th, 2009 at 6:29 am
jobs in modeling agencies
home
April 15th, 2009 at 5:51 am
marlboro cigarette comercial
future cadillac dts with dual clutch aut
April 15th, 2009 at 9:48 am
cosmetic pennsylvania surgeon
us free instant health insurance quotes
April 18th, 2009 at 7:15 am
gm concept car 2005
beijing china hotel map weather picture
June 14th, 2009 at 1:03 pm
Great blog! Loved the article. Thanks
June 14th, 2009 at 9:05 pm
Social Bookmarks Demon is enormously powerful, 100% automatic social bookmarking software which will build UNLIMITED number of top quality backlinks, send first-class traffic in minutes, increase your affiliate sales, AdSense income and site revenue as much as never. Social Bookmarks Demon combines features of ALL social bookmarking tools available in the market for price of single tool.
June 15th, 2009 at 9:00 am
Varying the anchor text in backlinks is a vital thing to do, making the text fit in in as natural a way as is humanely possible. I often see people using unnatural anchor text in their links and it would stick out like a sore thumb to Google et al in my opinion. The text has to be in context and read naturally to humans.
June 29th, 2009 at 11:00 am
Sometimes, I just don’t know what to think anymore.