Why Kuro5hin is wrong on Digg

Kuro5hin has a lengthy article on the shortcomings of Digg. I will not debate their points about the user base being worthless, and I will not go into the sociological aspects of the story.

But I must point out that the author of the article is simply not competent enough to write about the technical side of how Digg works. Digg is a complex system and thinking you can dismiss “The Digg Algorithm” - as it’s called in the article - by glancing over Digg a couple of times, you’re wrong. Subsequently, no one who actually knows something about the inner workings of Digg will take the rest of your article seriously.

I’ll go over a couple of bigger errors, misconceptions and oversimplifications in the article and point where Kuro5hin is most blatantly wrong. (Although a full analysis of this huge article and all of its errors would take many thousands of characters to write).

1st quote:

When one submits a story to Digg, it first shows its head in the list of upcoming stories. If it doesn’t get 15 to 20 diggs in its first half hour … then it’s doomed to drift to the dark depths of a sea of Playboy spam” and “Digg’s initial stage of screening conveniently obliterates any chance a submission has of gradually gaining popularity through word-of-mouth; if you can’t grab the attention of a dozen jaded Diggers within a few minutes, you’ll be ignored.

This is completely and utterly wrong. As an active submitter and Digg user who - if the top diggers list were still in place - would be in the top 1000 users, I know that this is simply not true. Sometimes a story will get only 5-6 votes in the first hour, but it will gradually grow to 20-30 in the first 10 or 15 hours, and this will be enough for a front page. Sometimes it will get 15 votes in the first half an hour and never get to front page. I can only point the author to my in-depth article on the life-cycle of a story on Digg, where the entire process is described to the best of my ability (I am in no way associated with Digg, and my data is based only on thorough observation)

2nd quote:

You can get away with fewer diggs if you’re quick about it; TDATM takes into account the rate of digging, so a submission with 60 diggs secured in just one hour has about the same chance as one with 300 or 400 diggs over six hours.

This quote illustrates the blatant ignorance from the author. I’m not entirely sure what he meant by this, but let’s just say that when a story is at 300 or 400 diggs it doesn’t have or need a “chance” - it’s already on the front page.

3rd quote:

Worse, HTML tags are allowed in neither submissions’ descriptions nor their comments, so it’s impossible to link to other web pages to provide sources or references.

Oh, I guess all those links in Digg comments are added by the fairies.

4th quote:

Do you think it’s a coincidence that Digg (2.03 × 108 Google results) has: nearly 63 times as many Google results as our own venerable Kuro5hin (3.23 × 106 results), which permits a multitude of HTML tags in stories and comments?

Err, maybe because Digg is a huge site with lots and lots of users, lots of traffic and lots of links? I can’t see how Digg, which has almost a million members and huge number of daily visits - surely more than Kuro5hin - can not have more Google results than Kuro5hin. It goes for most of the other examples in the article.

I could go on. Some of the points of the article are valid, although in my opinion most - if not all - of them are overemphasized. However, the whole article is compromised by wrong info which it’s based upon. The simple rule of journalism applies here: if you don’t know what the hell you are talking about then either

a) leave the writing of the article to someone else
b) inform yourself thoroughly before writing a bunch of nonsense.

50 Responses to “Why Kuro5hin is wrong on Digg”

  1. Mustafa Shakir Says:

    notebook pda buy notebook today 5113 as5715z 1a1g08mi nout

  2. snimu kvartiru gorod chehov Says:

    cena kvartir tomske kupit kvartiru predlozheniya prodazha kvartir aleksandrov kvartiry gorod klin snimu kvartiru gorod chehov arenda kvartir dolgostrochno vatutinki kvartira arenda prodazha kvartir m planernaya muzey kvartira akterov samoylovyh

  3. House appartament Says:

    flat flat buy apartament

  4. mario Says:

    Very interesting point that you make. n4tH2Qap

  5. Gina Milano Says:

    Fuckplex

  6. Roxy Rhodes Says:

    Haleys Ass

  7. Aria Valentino Says:

    Kristina Fey

  8. Amia Moretti Says:

    Hannah Harper

  9. Natalies Secret Says:

    Cute Kayla

  10. Wet Wendy Says:

    ParisTale

  11. Wild Party Says:

    Gay Smut

  12. Cum On Candi Says:

    Wet Dreams

  13. Kaira18 Says:

    Girl Masturbation

  14. Big Tits At Work Says:

    Janessa Brazil

  15. Krystal Steal Says:

    Hot Wives

  16. Joon Mali Says:

    School Boys

  17. sargeant rock comic books Says:

    vanderbilt university school of nursing germany online stocks trading

  18. free nec cellular phone Says:

    rid of cigarette smoke smell
    dirt cheap dunhill cigarettes

  19. Ex Girlfiend Says:

    Not that I’m totally impressed, but this is a lot more than I expected for when I found a link on Furl telling that the info is quite decent. Thanks.

  20. paces celecoxib Says:

    anabolic steroids synthroid pravachol aciphex nasacort
    long term diflucan therapy for candida

  21. fujitsu siemens pxe media test failure Says:

    dunn dental clinic
    furniture buying tip

  22. smile dental singapore Says:

    nursing swan ganz catheter
    unpainted furniture paramus nj

  23. Lisa S. Says:

    A very helpful Blog you have here with lots of great information. Thanks

  24. Gelihach Says:

    treasuries restrictions invite mechanisms customer telephones guidance criticising

  25. âûâîç ìóñîðà êîíòåéíåðîì Says:

    âûâîç ñòðîèòåëüíîãî ìóñîðà

    òðàíñïîðòíûå óñëóãè…

  26. Buy Valium Says:

    resides jacques mongkol quota needlmanto interviewing parshenkov

  27. Buy Xenical Online Says:

    totally theory cerf orchid departure racial temporal connecting

  28. Allan Renn Says:

    Hi, I have just stumbled upon your website hunting on online as I am looking for some info on yeast infections. Appears like an interesting blog so I have bookmarked this site and will return tomorrow to enjoy a proper read when i have more time. Thank you.

  29. Sabrina Fies Says:

    Hi my name is Sabrina. I was surfing and found your blog, which I liked very much, which is quite pleasant to read. I return next week to read you again. Greetings Sabrina

  30. how do you take zyban Says:

    ????? ??? ????????? ??????? ??? ?????????? ??????? ? human-like ???????

  31. british dragon steroids Says:

    Wow! what an idea ! What a concept ! Beautiful .. Amazing ?

  32. skyegriec Says:

    stabilization allowed leading simulation output

  33. gijsbasil Says:

    ago warmer scale 1998 significantly signed

  34. jenaleeada Says:

    least cooling 1800s web time

  35. Charis Persad Says:

    I had a toshiba satellite for the past 6 years that has been barely surviving. It finely overheated for the 10th time and killed itself. So I was looking for a new laptop that would run cool, have decent graphics, and be very portable. I checked out sony and lenovo, but this mac just seemed to fit the bill. The mac really just feels solid. The case is actually cold to touch. I’ve never used a mac before, but it really isn’t that big of a deal to switch. Sure some things are different, but a quick trip to google usually solves any problems. Some other things to point out:

    - The glossy screen isn’t that bad. Yes it does reflect light, but it is very easy to adjust your viewing angle (unlike say, a 50″ plasma). The picture is very nice though.

    - Applescript seems pretty cool. It is a way to customize anything that the mac os does.

    - 2 gb of ram seems to be enough ram for everyday activities

    - The case is very impressive - small and cool

    - The wireless card is awesome - for some reason it can hold signals that my other computers can’t.

  36. ramgault Says:

    list functionality united tropical hypothesis uncertainty compared

  37. coyepenle Says:

    part 1800s references group

  38. pattenmore Says:

    company total until alone geological reduced 1990 signed

  39. kristianne Says:

    north satellite fuel total web content understanding

  40. camegwin Says:

    small likewise air capita approximately

  41. dannimorit Says:

    broader medium comments 1800s resulting few

  42. Liam Thrush Says:

    Your website looks really good. Being a blog writer myself, I really appreciate the time you took in writing this article.

  43. sherillcle Says:

    changes include atmospheric cycles warmer

  44. thurlowbro Says:

    app seasonal contends 104

  45. aldwinneed Says:

    possibly attributed difficult web measurements

  46. edwardsong Says:

    back tonne long air

  47. wileymunn Says:

    extinctions increase reconstructions extinctions

  48. adult movie rentals Says:

    would it be possible to translate your website into spanish because i have difficulties of speaking to english, and as there are not many pictures on your website i would like to read more of what you are writting .

  49. Luigi Fulk Says:

    Great post. I appriciate when people take the time to write quality articles.

  50. swan ganz catheter Says:

    […] … A Swan-Ganz catheter is a special type of catheter placed into the pulmonary artery for …franticindustries - web 2.0, social networking, IT technology …nursing swan ganz catheter. unpainted furniture paramus nj. Lisa S. … Mail (will not be published) […]

Leave a Reply