So long, Photoshop - 6 online image editors reviewed
The title is, of course, a joke. If there’s any application that won’t easily be replaced by an online application, it’s Photoshop, one of the mightiest and most versatile software tools ever. Still, although Photoshop is bread and butter of every graphic designer, it’s a scourge of many offices, where poor users are struggling to use this powerful (and, for many, too complex) tool for actions which can be done with a much simpler piece of software. Add to that the fact that with huge popularity of Flickr and similar services a lot of user-generated photos have moved online, and it’s easy to see that online image editors are a great solution for simple and quick image editing.
Recently, a new online image editor - Picnik - appeared, and I’ve decided to compare it to five other similar applications (there are many more out there, but I felt that only these 6 are really mature products. If you know of any other great online image editors, please let me know). Here are the results.
Fauxto launches in a new window, which is unnecessary and will annoy many users. But when it opens up, you’ll be ready to forgive it, because it’s basically Photoshop’s little brother. It’s a very ambitious image editor: it has it’s own image format, it supports layers, several filters, 16 different tools including smudge, gradient fill, eyedropper…in one word, it’s as close to Photoshop as an online application can get.
This said, some options are sorely lacking. Zoom, for instance. Open up a big image and you simply can’t view it in its entirety. Also, the entire service seems to be leaning more to the drawing than the image editing features. I’m sure that many users would appreciate the ability to remove the red eye effect more than the ability to draw pretty radial gradients.
As far as stabilty goes, I’ve experienced one nasty problem. Every now and then, it stops reacting to clicks. It can also get generally slow at times. I haven’t noticed any other bugs, but these are bad enough and should be addressed quickly.
All in all, Fauxto beats the competition down with options, and you have to give them that. Looking at Fauxto blog you can see a stunning array of new fetures they’ve prepared for the next update. However, complexity is not exactly what most users will be looking for here, and Fauxto may be trying just a little too hard for its own good. The more features they add, the more will little inadequacies in the GUI stand out. But, if they manage to iron all the bugs out, Fauxto will be the online image editor of choice for many.
The youngest application in this roundup, Picnik is definitely among the best. It has a simple and very usable GUI and it guesses all those frequently used features right, so that even seasoned Photoshoppers won’t grumble that this or that is missing after 5 minutes of using the service. The approach is similar to that of Picasa: take the stuff that 99% of non-professionals actually need on a day to day basis, and cut out the rest.
What’s even better is that Picnik is quick and works really good, although it’s not without bugs. One weird bug emerged when I tried to set a fixed crop size: I was unable to set an exact number in pixels. I would type 358 and I would get 357. This doesn’t always happen, but it’s quite annoying and it needs to be fixed fast. While we’re on the subject of cropping, one important feature is missing. I would like to be able to set a fixed crop size and then set the size of the crop rectangle to what I want, so I can crop a larger area of the image down to a set pixel size, just like in Photoshop.
It’s important to note that, besides saving images to your computer or printing them, Picnik also integrates with Flickr for easy uploading of edited image.
Although tiny bugs are present, and certain less important features are lacking, Picnik is very close to a product I would use for work or even recommend to my entire office. It has a perfect balance of versatility and usability: it has everything you need for casual image editing without going too far in the options department.
Just like Picnik, Picture2Life makes the right decision by enabling you to try out the service without registering. Unfortunately, Picture2Life’s GUI leaves a lot to be desired. Some of the commands are unnecessarily crammed into a very small rectangle next to the image, and the options are presented as tags (you need to sign up to get the feel of the real GUI, it feels quite different than the tryout). There’s quite a bit of options, including some options none of the other apps included in this roundup have, for example animation and collage creation, and a live preview of all applicable effects at once. Personally, I’d rather have less options, but better organization.
Picture2Life also gives you a 25 MB storage space for your photos, or the ability to create a picture RSS feed, which makes for some interesting possibilities. But, I’ve had a hard time enjoying the service because the GUI is, simply, too crowded and inadequate for this type of application. After a thorough reorganization and repositioning of practically everything on the page, Picture2Life would be a great competitor in this space. Also, as you will see in the test below, some of its image processing algorithms can yield very strange results. Verdict: if you can get over the GUI, you’ll find that Picture2Life has something to offer, but it’s still has a long way to go.
Preloadr is tied to Flickr, and it only works with a Flickr account. This can be both a blessing and a curse, since it might lead to bigger adoption from Flickr users, but it will surely alienate everyone who’s not a Flickr user.
In any case, Preloadr integrates with Flickr rather nicely, it has a simple, clean design, and it’s quite easy to use. The tools include cropping (it’s simple, but it’s done right), resizing, rotating and flipping, with a couple of ‘advanced’ tools, including image layers, histogram, scaling, moving, adding text and color channel graduation. Several filters, like sharpening, brightness, inverse or grayscale are also included. Most of the commands and options open in a popup, which might not be the best choice but it works quite well.
There is no one-click-fix type of option, which is a shame, because many users would benefit from it. There is, however, an auto-contrast option, the results of which you can see below in my little test. Overall, Preloadr chooses its features wisely, taking care to include only the important stuff and leave out the clutter. It’s a bit of a shame that it’s aimed only at Flickr users, but if you are one, I can recommend it.
PXN8 earns points on simplicity. When you open the site, you’re greeted with an image and pretty well designed editing commands on the left. It has a great and fast zooming system, an auto-enhance feature (it could use a separate auto-colors feature, though), and the ability to crop, resize, and rotate the image. It also has color balancing, red eye removal, and several effects, some of which are dubbed as “fun” but are actually quite useful - rounded corners is one of them.
Like many other apps here, PXN8 fails at cropping. Many users are working in a CMS and have a custom format for their images. For example, the images on this site all have 500 pixel width. In PXN8 I can’t simply crop an area of the image down (or up) to 500 px width, which makes the crop feature almost useless. This feature can’t be too hard to code, so I expect PXN8 and other apps I’ve mentioned here will take notice and fix this annoyance.
PXN8 enables you to edit an image from your computer or from the web, and even includes a bookmarklet for easy adding of images from the web to the editor. From the editor, you can save the images to your computer or to Flickr, or upload it to MySpace, Bebo or other services via Webshots.
Apart from cropping, PXN8 works nice. Its GUI is decent but not beautiful, however it’s fast and for the most part bug-free, and that’s what most users will want. You can check out an example of its auto-enhance feature at the end of this text.
Snipshot is a bit of a mixed bag. It has a great GUI, works fast, and even offers a free API so you can include it on your own website. It offers unlimited undoing, and you can use it to edit fairly large images - up to 10 MBs.
On the other hand, its options, which include only resizing, simple cropping, rotation, an auto-enhance feature, and adjustments for sharpness, hue, saturation, brightness and contrast, are simply not enough. As a proof-of-concept it’s fantastic, but for everyday usage you’re going to miss some feature in the first 5 minutes.
So, the verdict here is simple: add some more features and more options (especially for cropping and resizing, which are currently free-form only), and it might just be the best application of this bunch. But at its current state, its adoption rate will stay low. It’s up to the developers to change this if they want growth.
The test
To test these applications, I’ve uploaded one overly dark photo and tried out the features users will probably be using the most: auto-fix, auto-colors, sharpen. Not all of the apps have the same features, so this is not a true comparison, but it will give you some idea how these image editors work in practice.. The results (with explanations) are below:
Original image
Fauxto (sharpen)
Picnik (1st image: auto-fix, 2nd image: auto-fix + auto-exposure + auto-colors)
Picture2Life (sharpen, value 6)
Preloadr (auto-contrast only)
PXN8 (enhance, essentially an auto-fix-all feature)
Snipshot (enhance, essentially an auto-fix-all feature)
Conclusion
As we’ve seen in the test, options are one thing, and real world usage is another. After applying some basic commands to the image, I’ve gotten very interesting results. Picnik’s auto-fix worked best, but its auto-colors did more harm than good, giving the image an unnatural blueish hue. The enhance feature of PXN8 definitely did too much (look at the loss of detail in the trees), while Snipshot’s was quite a bit better but still not perfect. Fauxto’s sharpen wasn’t useful at all (and interestingly enough, although Fauxto has the most options, when it comes to sharpening you only get one option: sharpen, without any additional settings). Preloadr’s auto-contrast was solid, producing similar results to Snipshot. Finally, I couldn’t find an auto-fix option in Picture2Life, so I tried with sharpen, but none of the settings produced remotely acceptable results.
As usual, there is no clear winner here, as each application offers something unique. For real everyday usage I would recommend Picnik and PXN8; you should definitely look at Fauxto if you want complexity and don’t mind a couple of bugs, while Snipshot is great if you want to include it on your own web site. Preloadr is good, but only for Flickr users, while Picture2Life needs a GUI overhaul and a change to some of its image processing algorithms, but it also offers several interesting and unique options. So, the moment when I’ll tell everyone in the office to ditch whatever software they’re using and switch to one of these apps is not yet here, but I feel it’s just around the corner.
February 3rd, 2007 at 1:10 pm
Great roundup!
I’ve heard of some of these before, and I’ve been directing people who use our CMS on an occasional basis to use PXN8 if they want to edit photos. Will take a look at piknic and see how it compares.
February 3rd, 2007 at 1:15 pm
@Rhys: thank you, it took me a while to do this one.
February 4th, 2007 at 5:59 am
You have a nice site. And a good alex standing .. But why don’t you have any advertising in here. With this kind of post and the traffic your site have.. I think you will have lot’s of income here. Anyway Thanks I have found your site. It’s another source of information.
February 4th, 2007 at 9:35 am
[…] Picnik - online photo editor. And for some reviews of online image editors see this FranticIndustries post: “So long photoshop”. A briefer “Online photo editing overview” is available at TechCrunch. […]
February 4th, 2007 at 1:37 pm
[…] Read FranticIndustries for their take as well. fauxto, Picnik, Picture2Life, Preloadr, PXN8, Snipshot Sphere It […]
February 9th, 2007 at 6:32 pm
Hi Stan,
This is the most thorough round-up of online photo editors I’ve seen yet (and I should know - I’ve been tracking this area for a while).
I take your point about the crop settings in Pixenate. It would be nice to be able to specify a fixed size to crop which is why I’ve just added this feature to pixenate.com.
Thanks once again for the feedback. If you’re interested send me an email and I’ll send you a link to some upcoming themes.
Walter Higgins
Founder & Lead Developer
Sxoop Technologies Ltd.
http://pixenate.com/
February 10th, 2007 at 4:13 pm
[…] Read FranticIndustries for their take as well. fauxto, Picnik, Picture2Life, Preloadr, PXN8, Snipshot […]
February 27th, 2007 at 1:18 pm
Hi Stan,
Well as Walter puts it, this was a great review! I also take note about your suggestions to Picture2Life, I really appreciate it. I agree it really needs an overhaul so thats what i’ve been working on for several months now (along with lots more new features and bug fixes).
My intensions are definately not to replace Photoshop (obviously) but still provide some of the basic functionality that I (for the life of me) couldn’t figure out the first time I used Photoshop. Also, make it easy for some people to do fun stuff with their pictures like create a collage or animate them. In the next release you should see much more of these fun features, plus lots of fixes and somewhat of a complete overhaul of the entire site.
So if you like, you can email me about anything and i’d be sure to get back to you. In the meantime, since your already a user, we’ll keep you updated about the new site’s progress. It should be ready by mid-next month, but we’ll see how that goes.
Again, thanks for the feedback!
Reymar Gooding
http://www.edityourpicture.com
March 2nd, 2007 at 2:50 am
What about Phixr?
March 28th, 2007 at 5:20 am
[…] However, this won’t help you when you actually try to develop such a service, as it’s pretty much all been done by Flickr and its many followers, most notably Google’s Picasa Web Albums. Even if you try developing a more specific service, like online photo editing, you will still get greeted by several solid products that are already doing it. […]
April 3rd, 2007 at 4:03 pm
cheapest propecia…
uomg ecicigo…
April 4th, 2007 at 3:04 pm
There is also on quite nice site for image processing, http://www.improveimages.com
it seems to at alpha stage. I have test it with some badly toned photos and it can correct them very well. There is only automatic correction.
April 7th, 2007 at 8:28 am
[…] Paul Graham is the founder of YCombinator, a venture company that invests into startups at a very early phase. Some of the startups they launched are Reddit, Kiko, Snipshot, YouOS, and Thinkature. […]
May 14th, 2007 at 5:13 am
[…] So long, Photoshop - 6 online image editors reviewed […]
June 12th, 2007 at 2:38 pm
[…] So, why do we, the Web 2.0 followers, feel like it’s too much? Well, because we’ve been following it all. From online photo editors to Twitter tools to RSS mixers to online operating systems. […]
June 14th, 2007 at 9:35 am
WipBox goes Free!…
When I built the first version of WipBox, it was created to help me sell my stuff in my move from LA back to the Bay Area. Although it had its bugs, it did exactly what it was designed for. It liquidated my extra stuff driving my moving costs from …
June 21st, 2007 at 3:14 am
[…] So long, Photoshop - 6 online image editors reviewed […]
June 21st, 2007 at 12:52 pm
[…] So long, Photoshop - 6 online image editors reviewed […]
June 21st, 2007 at 5:07 pm
Cool post.
You saved me lot of time to search for online image editors. Thanks!
June 23rd, 2007 at 4:54 pm
[…] So long, Photoshop - 6 online image editors reviewed […]
July 14th, 2007 at 9:40 am
Very useful post. Thank you.
July 15th, 2007 at 11:04 pm
WipBox launches WipBox Mobile!…
WipBox launches WipBox Mobile. Search for what something’s worth, right from an SMS-enabled phone.
……
August 3rd, 2007 at 2:16 pm
There’s a new iamge editing tool with some very unique features, not found in the usual online image editors. Check out www.ImageBling.com
August 27th, 2007 at 9:58 am
[…] In other news, Mashable writes about FotoFlexer, yet another online photo editor, that’s going to integrate with Facebook, MySpace, Flickr, Picasa and Yahoo soon. For a detailed review of 6 other online photo editors, go here. · del.icio.us it! · Slashdot it!· Stumble it!· Reddit it!· Netscape it!· Digg it!· […]
September 12th, 2007 at 3:10 am
[…] Remember our in-depth review of online photo editors? Well, as we’ve said at the initial announcement of a free online version of Photoshop, they might be out of business if Adobe does their job well. […]
September 15th, 2007 at 12:26 am
[…] Potem sem si ogledal katere od njih spletarji najraje uporabljajo (vir): […]
November 27th, 2007 at 2:47 am
[…] take my word for it: here are some other comparisons of online photo editing tools: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8. Your own opinion on any of these or other programs is welcome in the […]
December 18th, 2007 at 4:24 am
[…] been following online photo editors since they first appeared. I’ve even created an in-depth review of 6 most promising such products. After that, many new products appeared - I reckon there’s over 15 free online photo editors […]
December 19th, 2007 at 12:22 pm
[…] So long, Photoshop - 6 online image editors reviewed at franticindustries Includes Fauxto, Picnik, Picture2Life, Preloadr, PXN8 and Snipshot (tags: editors images online photography web2.0) […]
March 31st, 2008 at 4:08 am
[…] in the day I wrote a review of online photo editors, and my biggest concern with all of them was the lack of some web-oriented options, most notably […]
July 28th, 2008 at 8:58 am
Here’s a new one that’s simple to use. pictureful.com : Free online photo editor, decorate with overlays, remove red eye, simple zoom for crop, and resize.
September 23rd, 2008 at 12:06 pm
asdasdasd
October 5th, 2008 at 11:05 am
porfa kiero un collage
March 5th, 2009 at 7:07 pm
Interessante Informationen.
March 7th, 2009 at 6:23 am
Submit Links to Social Bookmarking Websites Automatically! Get Thousands of Visitors! Increase Website Traffic and Income with Automatic Social Bookmarks Submitter. Prepare to upgrade your servers today ? you will have thousands of real and highly targeted visitors who will make you the money like crazy!
March 30th, 2009 at 4:06 am
Well as Walter puts it, this was a great review! I also take note about your suggestions to Picture2Life, I really appreciate it. I agree it really needs an overhaul so thats what i’ve been working on for several months now. My intensions are definately not to replace Photoshop but still provide some of the basic functionality that I couldn’t figure out the first time I used Photoshop. Also, make it easy for some people to do fun stuff with their pictures like create a collage or animate them. In the next release you should see much more of these fun features, plus lots of fixes and somewhat of a complete overhaul of the entire site.
April 4th, 2009 at 5:21 am
PHPDug Social Poster enables you promoting unlimited number of domains on autopilot. Moreover, software not only bookmarks domains automatically, it also creates unlimited number of social accounts automatically! Domains and accounts are rotated randomly, so each your bookmark looks like posted by real person! Get ready for massive traffic - PHPDug Social Poster will start sending thousands of real visitors to your websites today!
April 9th, 2009 at 4:56 pm
I really liked your blog! i read 4 others that are on similar subjets, but they domt update very often, thanks.
April 10th, 2009 at 1:54 am
cosmetic surgery burns
new
April 18th, 2009 at 7:36 am
louisville cosmetic surgery
inspecta car
April 19th, 2009 at 1:55 pm
informative piece there, Thanks for this.its wonderfull to see someone with a like mind.
June 14th, 2009 at 7:14 pm
synthroid to cytomel conversion…
synthroid vs levothyroxine. what side effects does synthroid have. taking synthroid and nexium together. desiccated thyroid verses synthroid. split dose of synthroid. …
June 20th, 2009 at 6:27 pm
tamiflu effective h5n1…
tamiflu veterinary. tamiflu 75. . tamiflu stable. …
July 13th, 2009 at 2:38 am
chance visiting rights surgery wyeth amunicipal room convert
July 14th, 2009 at 5:52 pm
maintains hernando best introduced kreuh classifier assignment
July 16th, 2009 at 6:11 am
recorders execute essen cynical classroomthe copyrighted attendee statesberlin
October 5th, 2009 at 3:27 pm
Hello everyone,
If you’re interested in the image editors listed here I thought you might be interested in a Flash Image Editing application we have been working on. It can access your webcam, use preset styles, layers and a lot more. It’s not as sophisticated as some of the others I’ve seen but it’s got a lot of good features for doing the basic stuff that most people will want to do. You can create nice flyers, business cards, use templates and load photos from any url on the web. You can see a demo at www.flashimageeditor.com. I hope you like it!
October 18th, 2009 at 12:19 pm
PianoMan…
Thanks heaps for this!… if anyone else has anything, it would be much appreciated. Great website HOT Pianoforte Links http://www.de.Grand-Pianos.org Enjoy!…
October 24th, 2009 at 9:05 pm
Cheap Propecia…
The title is of course a joke. If there’s any application that won’t easily be replaced […]…
November 20th, 2009 at 8:50 pm
Propecia…
The title is of course a joke. If there’s any application that won’t easily be replaced […]…
December 11th, 2009 at 7:09 pm
http://www.eastfilters.com
Auto Filters, Replacement Elements For Fuel Filters, Turbine Fuel Filters, Replacement for Fuel Filters, Air Filters, Filter Water Separators, Fuel Purification Systems, Engine Fuel Filters, Gasoline Engine Fuel Filter, Diesel Engine Fuel Filter, Trailer Engine Fuel filter, Engine Fuel filter, Car Filter, auto fuel filters, Truck Fuel Filter and Motor Yacht parts.
January 3rd, 2010 at 4:14 am
Hi! MqWKWow
January 3rd, 2010 at 8:24 pm
I love the tips on this site, they are always to the point and just the information I was looking for. Its hard to find good content these days in the world of spam and garbage sites.
January 7th, 2010 at 12:20 pm
Is this sold in stores if so where?
January 8th, 2010 at 11:17 pm
Clear and concise post
January 11th, 2010 at 6:43 am
??????? ????
????? ?????????? ?????? ????? (?? ? ? ?????? ????? ???? :)).
January 13th, 2010 at 12:25 pm
?, ???? ? ?? ?????????? ????????, ?? ??? ?? ?????????. ?? ??? ???? ????? ?????? ????????. ?????? ????? ????? ???? ?????? ? ???????????. ??? ???, ??? ?????????, ?????? ???? ????!
January 15th, 2010 at 1:54 pm
Fantastic, thanks for revealing this.
January 17th, 2010 at 6:03 am
ywqcqoiemtfzeqezbgeebhshivuxut
January 22nd, 2010 at 10:22 am
This is a huge point, I wish I would have thought of this earlier.
January 28th, 2010 at 10:57 am
flxrowzpxomathjqmtuqqznnblyxhc
January 30th, 2010 at 10:13 pm
I was just chatting with my friend about this yesterday over lunch . Don’t know how in the world we got on the subject really, they brought it up. I do recall eating a wonderful steak salad with sunflower seeds on it. I digress…
February 2nd, 2010 at 5:09 am
These are so gorgeous! I love the two bottom ones! Fantastic, unlike all the rest you see these days..Great blog btw:).
February 4th, 2010 at 3:24 pm
Will anyone be in a position to smell a smoke smell on me?
February 6th, 2010 at 8:43 am
I need to shed pounds quickly will this work for me?
February 8th, 2010 at 1:18 pm
Hi there ! If you need someone to make your product or service be developed in France, don’t hesitate to contact me. I’m based in Paris core next to the “Champs Elys?es”. You can see what I’m able to provide you by consulting my linkedin profile . If you need to contact me, please do it via skype : sebastien.landrieu and/or by email : sebastien.landrieu@gmail.com