The community that does the right thing
There’s a new community/social content site in town - dotherightthing.com. The basic concept is digg-like: users submit stories, and vote on them. However, although the content technically is links to other content, the idea is different: they link to actions of companies, individuals and other entities that make a social impact, while the users vote whether these actions are important, and if yes, are they positive or negative, and whether their impact will be severe or mild.
The users are divided into two categories: representatives and personal users. The first group represent a company or some other entity, acting as a spokesperson and trying to supply valuable information about the company. The other group acts as a collective conscience, judging whether the company and its actions are good or evil.
Essentially, dotherightthing is a reputation builder.
Mike Arrington over at Techcrunch has a pretty negative review of the service, criticizing it for being for-profit, and the immaturity of its community. I can’t agree with the for-profit argument; this site can be called an activist site, but they are basically just another community like Reddit, Netscape, Digg or many others, which also needs funding to go on. The fact that a site deals with activist/green/environmental/sustainable development and similar subjects should not automatically mean that they aren’t allowed to make money, especially if it’s through advertising.
The community, on the other hand, is just that: a community. You can’t really control it, contain it, or teach it how to act and what to link. I agree that the quality of the submissions and the comments will make a big impact on the success of dotherightthing.com, however I cannot blame the service if the users aren’t exactly the intellectual elite.
The bottom line, for me, is that I like the idea. I feel that dotherightthing.com is doing something new in the social content / social news arena. While users of Netscape, Digg, Reddit and other similar sites can only bury something, decreasing its visibility and making it nonimportant, users at dotherightthing.com can vote on something negatively, and at the same time draw attention to this negativity. This is a novelty, and novelty is good. Add to this that the site itself is designed well and seems to be superbly coded, and I can only wish them luck and a thriving community.
January 29th, 2007 at 12:35 am
Thanks for the very well-written post and support. You nailed dotherightthing better than anyone has so far… too many people are confusing the utilization of collaborative information sharing and sorting technology similar to Digg, to solve a problem, with creating yet another Digg-like service. When we set out to start dotherightthing, we wanted to recognize companies for doing the right thing, and measure this type of impact, or non-financial performance, for all companies that people care about, in real time. It was that simple. The methods using which we accomplished these goals simply came about from a thorough evaluation of all of our options… and dotherightthing, as it exists today, was born. It is powerfully community driven, flexible, and it, as you mentioned above, has all the potential in the world to revolutionize how companies impact people and the world.
We’re exited to have you as a member of the dotherightthing community.
January 29th, 2007 at 12:37 am
@Ryan: Thanks for the kind words, and yes, I’ll make sure to follow (and actively participate in) what’s happening at dotherightthing in the future.
July 15th, 2009 at 8:47 am
The ball?s equator
November 11th, 2009 at 9:48 pm
Girls are most afraid of cold feet, particularly in winter, if they are not protect their feet well from cold, it will be easier to affect the health of women. So, choose a pair of warm and comfortable australia boot is very important. It is well-know that UGG is a warm autumn and winter boots, the more emphasis on style, a pair of winter can guarantee that your feet comfortable and warm, 09 new autumn and winter UGG boots snow is easier than ever with style snow boots! Fashion Ugg boots can not just to keep feet warm and you will find that they are out to dinner, on the dance floor, at work or even when on holiday either when skiing or on the beach. In a word, they can be worn in almost any weather without your feet getting either cold or overheated, and their neutral colour tones allow them to be worn with a wide variety of clothing, even True Religion Jeans .No matter what look you are trying to achieve, the Ugg boot can help you to achieve it.UGG,the warmest present in this winter. Log in http://www.ugg24hours.com/
December 18th, 2009 at 8:57 am
Hola, mi nombre es Sabrina y estube buscando por internet, fue entonces que encontre tu blog, el cual me gusto mucho, el cual es bastante agradable para leer. Regreso la proxima semana para leerte de nuevo. Saludos Sabrina
January 14th, 2010 at 6:19 pm
Automatic Scuttle Submitter is 100% automatic social bookmarking software designed to submit your domains to thousands of Scuttle sites. Not only Automatic Scuttle Submitter creates accounts and bookmarks sites automatically, but also parses meta tags for each URL and runs itself in background without any user interaction.
January 18th, 2010 at 10:04 am
I completely adore this blog, definitely gonna have to put this on the list.
February 15th, 2010 at 2:17 pm
hey this blog is great. I’m glad I came by this blog. Maybe I can contribute in the near future. PM ME on Yahoo AmandaLovesYou702 Thank you day562
February 26th, 2010 at 11:05 am
I’ve happened to be searching all over for this particular material. Thankfully I noticed this in Bing.
ROMANA