File downloading, if not for profit, not illegal in Italy?

According to this report, the high court of Italy ruled that downloading (copyrighted) files - be it software, music, or movies - is not illegal if profit is not the motivation. The case in question was a lawsuit against two students who set up a p2p file-sharing network, and who were initially sentenced to one year in prison. But the highest judicial institution in Italy overthrew the decision, and set the two students free.

This is an important decision, because RIAA’s brainwash is lately succeeding in pushing the notion that p2p file sharing is a criminal activity per se. It’s good to hear that judicial bodies in some countries understand that listening to a song on the radio, sharing a mix-tape with a friend, and sharing files on a p2p network - if not for financial gain - do not automatically make you a criminal.

Unfortunately, despite this small victory, this is still an uphill battle in Italy. SIAE (Italian Assocication of Authors - think of it as the Italian RIAA) issued a statement in which it pointed out that within current legislation, which entered into force after this case, file-sharing (even if not for profit) is illegal.

In any case, this might be a good time to remember my old list of all the countries in which P2P sharing can most definitely cost you money, and possibly even your freedom.

63 Responses to “File downloading, if not for profit, not illegal in Italy?”

  1. Matt Says:

    Well, at least it’s a step in the right direction.
    What really infuriates me is that the RIAA needs to understand that their industry is dying, and instead of spending their money trying to put the file-swappers in jail, use it to bring music fully into the digital sector.
    Instead of whining about dwindling sales (which may or may not be true), do the best to take advantage of the internet’s massively accessible market.

  2. baron Says:

    All jokes aside this is the way it should be. So you have 80GB of downloaded content on your hard disk? Do you actually have any time to watch it? Equating this with murder and drug dealing is a no go for the digital age. Just make them delete everything. If it’s for profit, then charge them. If they distribute it over the network, keep them away from computers and the internet for a couple months (this will hurt them more than any fine).

  3. Stan Schroeder Says:

    The point I’m always trying to get accross is this: P2P content sharing is exactly the same as copying your favorite audio tape and giving it to your friend. The fact that it’s done on a much broader scale does not make it intrinsically evil.

  4. links for 2007-01-28 at Baron VC Says:

    […] File downloading, if not for profit, not illegal in Italy Is Italy the only country with any sanity? All the restrictions that come with copyrighted content feels like Big Brother 2.0. (tags: p2p) […]

  5. Nova Says:

    It’s an uphill battle that I’m sure we’ll win. No-one can fight technology forever.

  6. mani Says:

    Thats some good news but there is a bit of ambiguity here… profit is not necessarily financial.. it can be barter system like u share this song and i share that one ..or u can argue that there is a implicit moral code of any p2p network is to share what u download.. under such circumstances is it wise to state that there is no profit?no monetary profit certainly but what about data and information ?

  7. File downloading, if not for profit, not illegal in Italy « Ctrl + Alt + Delete Says:

    […] read more | digg story […]

  8. stinky wizzleteeks Says:

    i wonder what convinced them to one year in prison.

  9. Zack Says:

    I don’t understand why people insist on the high-risk activity of downloading when they can just share media like CDs between friends. Your downloading should be limited to content that you cannot obtain any other way.

  10. Simone Says:

    The point here is that the processing refers to a “crime” that has been made before the introduction of the so-called “Decreto Urbani” (Urbani’s law), which says that you are liable for piracy even without profitability.

    The point of discussion, before the introduction of such a law, was about profit: was the simple savings caused but the non-buying of something a profit? This time, the judge said no.

  11. Dictionary Brown Says:

    I believe it is also legal to download copyrighted files in Japan.

    It is not legal to distribute copyrighted files without permission though.

    This makes filesharing systems fairly suspect… but just plain leeching OK?

    Gotta love it.

  12. Stan Schroeder Says:

    @everyone: sorry about the “convinced” lapsus calami. My fingers were faster than my brain.

  13. Miketrevis Says:

    warning: isn’t true for the new italian legislation.

  14. Stan Schroeder Says:

    @Miketrevis: yes, it’s written at the end of the article. I just couldn’t cram all the relevant info into the title.

  15. Nookdo » File downloading, if not for profit, not illegal in Italy Says:

    […] If only we could get the same ruling in England!read more | digg story Bookmark to:          […]

  16. nicola Says:

    As stated by Miketrevis this isn’t true for the new legislation

  17. Jessica Says:

    Elaine, you are just to funny. Don’t ever loose your sense of humor.
    wallmart

  18. Freud Says:

    Wow! Thank you! I always wanted to write in my site something like that. Can I take part of your post to my blog?

  19. Tera Says:

    While downloading files from rapidshare (using http://rapidqueen.com/ ), I don’t think much if it is legal or illegal. What is so bad in my desire to watch a movie or listen to a song?

  20. skitoscipsy Says:

    http://rilulwg.100webspace.net/xiarnghee.html role of nurse practitioners

  21. Gristcors Says:

    http://top-10.fox.ixk.name/map.html compare new cars vehicles

  22. Erurpambcurry Says:

    http://khfuq.eu.interia.pl/zect.html best hot tub leak repair liquid

  23. metro dentalcare richfield Says:

    plant nursery for retirement income
    infiniti power supplies

  24. Kutt Says:

    I’m glad I saw this, kudos!

  25. wendydawson Says:

    Check out VerifiedFile.com ( http://verifiedfile.com ) SEO marketing services to promote websites, products & services on targeted forums, blogs and message boards worldwide. The best way to gain notoriety.

  26. Span Says:

    Excellent blog, I’ll be coming back to visit more often now. Keep up the great work.

  27. Cassata Says:

    Excellent blog, I’ll be coming back to visit more often now. Keep up the great work.

  28. Cardine Says:

    Hello,

    very nice blog, good work, nice to read.

    regards

    Reifen

  29. Clendening Says:

    Do you write the articles yourself or do you get somebody to write out your ideas for me? As when i tried blogging I was nowhere near this good! http://streamyx-dialup20181.blogspot.com/2009_03_31_archive.html

  30. Wassum Says:

    Ha!

    You would think that they world have OK’d it at the beginning instead of allowing it to go so long without saying a thing and then bringing it back up when it was too late. I don’t understand it at all. Vivaxa

  31. Streaming-Anime Says:

    Thanks for your article! I will check back for more interesting articles

  32. Vitello Says:

    Hey there, Great Articl! Feel free to submit your site to our Directory Free. Free Website Promotion

  33. harvardgrads Says:

    Where can I find a free anonymous web proxy to visit MySpace & Facebook? My school blocks these site. Any ideas?

  34. princemichaels Says:

    http://Go31.com is a fast, free & secure Web Proxy Solution to browse the web.

  35. Hutti Says:

    Ha!

    You would think that they world have OK’d it at the beginning instead of allowing it to go so long without saying a thing and then bringing it back up when it was too late. I don’t understand it at all. Ultra Hair Away

  36. Crespin Says:

    That was a great post…I love this site. Thanks

  37. Houston Says:

    Excellent post, keep it up

  38. Desper Says:

    Excellent post, keep it up

  39. Linenberger Says:

    Like your website, very well done. Check my website

  40. Falconi Says:

    Awesome info! I was honestly just thinking about something similar to this the other day so, it was almost “weird” when I ran across this. You would be surprised how many people simply have no idea when it comes to this kind of stuff. Anyway, thanks for getting this info out there and I’m sure I’m not the only one who appreciates you taking the time to post this for the masses.

  41. Rayos Says:

    That was a great post…I love this site…Thanks

  42. Andress Says:

    Great post … I love this site…Thanks

  43. Bostrom Says:

    Love this post! Great blog! I’m doing articles on Super Smash Bros Brawl feel free to write back sometime! http://www.rofasbiweeklies.info

  44. Yarnell Says:

    Thanks for the interesting article

    http://goodoletom.com/store

  45. Demaria Says:

    I Love the way you write…thanks for posting

  46. Johnstad Says:

    I Love the way you write…thanks for posting

  47. Konecny Says:

    My favorite file hosting service is www.m9dia.com. Unlike other hosting services, m9dia does not have any advertising, waiting times, queues, download limits or whatsoever.

  48. Gazzo Says:

    Thanks for sharing this. Great! http://www.bestccnow.com

  49. Wakeman Says:

    You really should make a captcha and stop this spam comments… smieszne filmy

  50. Soplop Says:

    I Love the way you write…thanks for posting

  51. Engles Says:

    I Love the way you write…thanks for posting

  52. Roane Says:

    I Love the way you write…thanks for posting

  53. Meland Says:

    What a world we live in!! It just shows us all up to the fools we are… http://www.wordlinksdirectory.co.uk

  54. Beekman Says:

    Some time back, my 3-year old computer was running so slow that I had to buy a new computer. Or at least I thought I needed a new computer. Then within a matter of weeks of surfing on the Internet, my new computer was also running so slowly. In addition, some programs did not run well on my computer, and I did not recognize some of the programs that were running on my computer. That scared me most. Were these programs that were tracking my keystrokes on my computer or programs I just not remember installing? I knew I had to find a answer and solution fast. The truth is, we can all put up with a slow computer, but very few of us would want others to have access to the information on our computers, but that is exactly what can happen when spyware or malware is loaded on our computers without our knowledge. Extenze

  55. Chirco Says:

    Some time back, my 3-year old computer was running so slow that I had to buy a new computer. Or at least I thought I needed a new computer. Then within a matter of weeks of surfing on the Internet, my new computer was also running so slowly. In addition, some programs did not run well on my computer, and I did not recognize some of the programs that were running on my computer. That scared me most. Were these programs that were tracking my keystrokes on my computer or programs I just not remember installing? I knew I had to find a answer and solution fast. The truth is, we can all put up with a slow computer, but very few of us would want others to have access to the information on our computers, but that is exactly what can happen when spyware or malware is loaded on our computers without our knowledge. VPRX

  56. Depaul Says:

    Some time back, my 3-year old computer was running so slow that I had to buy a new computer. Or at least I thought I needed a new computer. Then within a matter of weeks of surfing on the Internet, my new computer was also running so slowly. In addition, some programs did not run well on my computer, and I did not recognize some of the programs that were running on my computer. That scared me most. Were these programs that were tracking my keystrokes on my computer or programs I just not remember installing? I knew I had to find a answer and solution fast. The truth is, we can all put up with a slow computer, but very few of us would want others to have access to the information on our computers, but that is exactly what can happen when spyware or malware is loaded on our computers without our knowledge. Semenax

  57. Starns Says:

    I Love the way you write…thanks for posting

  58. Spieler Says:

    Some time back, my 3-year old computer was running so slow that I had to buy a new computer. Or at least I thought I needed a new computer. Then within a matter of weeks of surfing on the Internet, my new computer was also running so slowly. In addition, some programs did not run well on my computer, and I did not recognize some of the programs that were running on my computer. That scared me most. Were these programs that were tracking my keystrokes on my computer or programs I just not remember installing? I knew I had to find a answer and solution fast. The truth is, we can all put up with a slow computer, but very few of us would want others to have access to the information on our computers, but that is exactly what can happen when spyware or malware is loaded on our computers without our knowledge. Male TRX

  59. Sussman Says:

    Thanks for this. Bookmarking your blog.

  60. Lowenstein Says:

    I Love the way you write…thanks for posting

  61. Juliar Says:

    Thanks for this. Bookmarking your blog.

  62. Precella Says:

    thanks! just what I was looking for :)

  63. Spates Says:

    thanks! just what I was looking for :)

Leave a Reply