Template Pligg startup = bad idea
I’m always glad when new web startups send me notice about their site. This said, lately I have been getting a lot of mail from new social content Pligg-based sites based on a very slightly (or not at all) altered basic Pligg design template.
I won’t go into individual sites, but you can find many of them here.
I know Pligg is notoriously hard to customize (this deserves an entire post, and I’ll get to that someday). But still, making a new site on a widely available design template is a horrible idea, and you’re likely to get little or no media coverage for it. If you cannot visually distinguish your site from hundreds of other sites, it seriously cripples your business - even if you have the best business idea in the world. Would you visit a Digg-like site that looked exactly like Digg? I didn’t think so.
This said, here are a couple of ideas that might help a young entrepreneur with a Pligg based site distinguish his site from the rest.
- Choose a minimalistic, simple design template for Pligg, like this one (have in mind that this template isn’t yet available for the latest version of Pligg), and then modify that. On a simple design like that, small changes like a logo or a different font might be enough for your site to establish a different visual identity.
- Reduce a template. If you’re not on good terms with PHP, creating or even changing an existing Pligg template might be a very hard task. But simply reducing some of the graphical elements might be enough to make a difference. Here’s a site that did a decent job by simply removing some elements of one of Pligg’s default themes.
- Buy a template. Here is one designer who is selling Pligg templates. You might be able to find others on the official Pligg forums. The cost might not be as high as you’d expect, and many people are ready to help for a small fee.
- A variation of the above is to design a template in Photoshop (or have a professional designer do it for you) and then post it on the Pligg forums, offering to pay for someone to turn the design into a full template.
- Join forces with a coder/designer. Many people like to operate alone (me included), so they like the idea of having a platform that enables them to build a site from the ground up with little or no programming knowledge. Pligg is not that platform (yet). It works out of the box, but almost any modifications you might want to do will require a lot of time and effort - especially if you’re not a PHP expert. *This is what I’m doing as well - I have ideas and half-finished sites but no time and PHP knowledge to do all the modifications I deem necessary to make the site really great. If any web coder/designer is interested in helping me building a Pligg based site or perhaps even implement a completely new Digg-like platform, maybe we can join forces and create something together. Contact me at franticindustries (at) gmail (dot) com.
January 21st, 2007 at 9:08 am
I aggree, i have a CS degree and have a pretty good knowledge of PHP and i still found pligg obscure and frustrating, and yet out of the digg clones it has the best features. I think the first step is to move away from smarty templates.
They need to either go completely down the CMS route ala joomla or make them a series of scripts that we can adapt into our sites. This middle ground that they are inhabiting just leads to a bunch of sites that look the same. Ugly.
I think videosift.com are about the best around. But they had a team of about 7 developers working on that thing.
January 21st, 2007 at 1:03 pm
@richard: I myself am working on some social content sites, and I’m trying out Drupal 5.0 atm. If I find it good, I just might give up on Pligg, at least until the next major release.
January 25th, 2007 at 9:33 pm
I’d have to agree with Richard as well. I’ve been working on an alternative and renewable energy news site, alternativee.org. I have a CS background and it took me a while to understand the Pligg templates and code well enough to make changes. I also don’t use several Pligg features, but it appears that a large chunk of code still gets executed with every page load — if my site every got popular I’d be concerned about the effect of all that extra code execution on the server.
January 25th, 2007 at 11:43 pm
@Greg: One approach I’ve recently heard of is to use an older version of Pligg. Less features, but faster, less bloaty, and easier to configure.
January 31st, 2007 at 10:46 am
What about mine?
I changed the colors on a stock template and tried to minimilize it a bit. I think I have a good name, considering how hard they are to come by these days. I would appreciate any suggestions on the design or the content.
January 31st, 2007 at 10:48 am
Oh, it didn’t take my link. You can click my user name to get to www.favester.com
March 9th, 2007 at 3:01 pm
[…] Besides just plain voting, users can also try to predict whether a company will get bought out, receive VC funding, offer its stocks on the stock market through an IPO, or maybe just linger on or completely die out. The concept seems to be working well, because this month and a half old site is already experiencing a fair amount of activity. The fact that the design site is not just a plain vanilla Pligg template (which is in most cases a quick road to oblivion) helps too. […]
April 19th, 2007 at 10:17 am
[…] Secondly, the site offers nothing new. You have news, voting buttons, a selection of topics to browse from, and that’s it. Oh yeah, I forgot: a lot of adds too. There’s no upcoming page. There are no different ways to view content. There’s nothing new or interesting here: your average run of the mill Pligg site offers more options. […]
May 1st, 2007 at 11:37 am
[…] Tasarımcılar için ÅŸimididen baÅŸlayacakları pligg arayüzleri ile ilgili tasarım çalışmaları ileride güzel bir geri dönüş saÄŸlayabilir. […]
July 18th, 2007 at 5:40 pm
As someone with very limited PHP knowledge/experience, I’m finding Pligg to be VERY difficult, even impossible to customize. For some reason, it pulls only half of the CSS info and there’s no pattern. Also, the use of template file upon template file upon template file upon template file seems to hurt it. For example, why have the structure template (pligg.tpl) call the meta.tpl file? The answer: to make meta configurable template-wide. Of course, if you put all that meta info in the pligg.tpl, it is still a one-step process to edit for the whole site. Also, the “center” stuff seems unnecessary. The code looks messy and, from what I’ve read here, is not user friendly, even for experts.
It seems it’s designed not to be customized, but for templates to be purchased from those who already know the pligg system. I’m open to other CMS systems like it, where visitors can submit/vote on articles. Can you recommend any that are stable and don’t require a PhD in CS to implement into a template (like ones found on oswd.org? If so, email me (webmaster@faithtag.com).
July 18th, 2007 at 5:46 pm
[…] Today, 08:46 PM Streamlined coding! I was looking for info on customizing a template to work with Pligg and ran across this article. It seems even experienced programmers have trouble with it and would like a more simple system. My biggest difficulty is the number of .tpl files that seem unnecessary. For example, pligg.tpl calls the meta.tpl file. Since pligg.tpl is the framework, why put the meta in another .tpl? I’m sure much of the info can be reduced to less files. I’ve got a template design I like, but can’t seem to get it to work in pligg. […]
September 26th, 2007 at 4:45 pm
[…] Template Pligg startup = bad idea […]
October 9th, 2007 at 1:55 am
[…] effort into developing this one. The idea, while OK, is not revolutionary either. And, as we know, vanilla Pligg sites don’t fare too well. Actually, the only reason why anyone would ever report on this is the fact that it’s Intel […]
October 17th, 2007 at 1:05 am
I have experience with php and got some job as cms implementor but for me, pligg’s template is not easy. Move away from smarty templates … I agree.
October 31st, 2007 at 6:52 am
Very good post… true… Pligg is very difficult to customize… even if you’re a well-rounded php’er.
December 7th, 2007 at 1:09 pm
Why Pligg guys pay less attention on template. Like joomla and wordpress, they could make it more friendly. Language file should be separated for different locale. Most of the pligg templates are craps. I see Pligg code is broken for XHTML and CSS but Templates should follow css and optimization. After researching and analyzing different site I got only one good company named Moonrank USA (http://www.moonrank.com)who is fully dedicated for pligg. Also one Australian guy is doing good work.
May 17th, 2008 at 1:31 am
I would be happy to help anyone with customizing their pligg site with an entirely new look.
Just head over to the (nearly ready to launch)www.pliggskins.com and get in touch.
June 29th, 2008 at 9:41 am
I just started a pligg based site and have to completely agree. The learning curve was rather steep, and I am still trying to wrap my mind around some of the code (in an attempt to remove the bloat).
August 24th, 2008 at 5:18 pm
Actually Pligg isnot hard to customize at all. Once you figure out where everything is located, it doesn’t take long to make your own design.
I have a bunch of FREE templates for Pligg at my website for anyone looking to grab a template that isn’t the default.
April 9th, 2009 at 12:59 am
After reading the article, I just feel that I really need more information on the topic. Could you share some resources please?
April 18th, 2009 at 7:13 am
new york antique furniture auction val kill roosevelt
american jobs in russia
June 5th, 2009 at 12:42 pm
I will be linking back I really like your site keep up the good work.
June 19th, 2009 at 7:30 am
Fix My Script offers practical, low cost script installation and website building solutions for people with high standards. Our proven expertise and total commitment to quality enables us to provide the most comprehensive service in the industry. Fix My Script programmers can install, debug and test PHP scripts, fix script problems and errors.